Switch not working properly

I'm using a switch in order to understand which button was clicked. There are 6 total buttons. I'm using this:

public void characterClick(View v){
    if(status){
        switch (v.getId()){
            case R.id.first:
                demoniacList.add(new Demoniac());
                first.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.second:
                guardList.add(new Guard());
                second.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.third:
                masonsList.add(new Masons());
                masonsList.add(new Masons());
                third.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.fourth:
                mediumList.add(new Medium());
                fourth.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.fifth:
                if (demoniacList.size() + guardList.size() + masonsList.size() +
                        mediumList.size() + villagerList.size() + werehamsterList.size() < players.size()-1) {
                    villagerList.add(new Villager());
                } else {
                    villagerList.add(new Villager());
                    fifth.setEnabled(false);
                }
            case R.id.sixth:
                werehamsterList.add(new Werehamster());
                sixth.setEnabled(false);
        }
    } else {
        switch (v.getId()){
            case R.id.first:
                demoniacList.remove(demoniacList.size()-1);
                first.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.second:
                guardList.remove(guardList.size()-1);
                second.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.third:
                masonsList.remove(masonsList.size()-1);
                masonsList.remove(masonsList.size()-1);
                third.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.fourth:
                mediumList.remove(mediumList.size()-1);
                fourth.setEnabled(false);
            case R.id.fifth:
                villagerList.remove(villagerList.size()-1);
                if(villagerList.size() == 0){
                    fifth.setEnabled(false);
                }
            case R.id.sixth:
                werehamsterList.remove(werehamsterList.size()-1);
                sixth.setEnabled(false);
        }
    }
}

Each button should run the same method but each single button has a different case in the switch so each button has a different behavior.

Now, when I click the Guard one (the second) 4 buttons get disabled in total, not just the Gurad one as it should be instead.

Any ideas why? If you think I should add more code just tell me in the Idea!